blog home Domestic Abuse False Accusations in San Diego Domestic Violence Cases

False Accusations in San Diego Domestic Violence Cases

By San Diego Attorney on August 9, 2025

Being falsely accused of domestic violence is a horrible experience. In San Diego and throughout California, these allegations can lead to immediate legal consequences—arrest, protective orders, loss of custody rights, and a potential criminal record—even before your side of the story is heard.

False accusations are unfair and life-altering. If you are facing a false domestic violence accusation in San Diego, you need to act quickly and decisively. The legal system is not forgiving, and the burden falls on the accused to fight back.

At jD Law Criminal Defense Attorneys, we have defended clients throughout San Diego County against unfounded domestic violence claims.

Why Do False Domestic Violence Accusations Happen?

False domestic violence allegations can occur in a range of emotionally charged scenarios. Some of the most common motives include:

• Custody or divorce disputes: One party may try to gain an advantage in family court by portraying the other as dangerous or abusive.
• Revenge or retaliation: Following a breakup, argument, or perceived betrayal.
• Immigration or housing benefits: In rare cases, a person may file a false claim to obtain legal or financial benefits.
• Mistaken identity or misunderstanding: Events may be misrepresented, exaggerated, or taken out of context.

Unfortunately, the system tends to err on the side of caution in domestic violence cases. This means police officers often arrest the alleged aggressor on the spot, and prosecutors may move forward with charges even when the accuser wants to drop the case.

Immediate Consequences of a False DV Allegation

If you have been falsely accused, the legal process moves quickly. You may face:

• Arrest and booking
• Mandatory cooling-off period in jail
• An emergency or temporary restraining order
• A formal criminal complaint filed by the San Diego District Attorney

These early stages can shape the entire outcome of the case, so having an experienced criminal defense lawyer on your side from the beginning is essential.

What Is Domestic Violence Under California Law?

California Penal Code § 243(e)(1) and § 273.5 define domestic violence as any willful infliction of bodily injury or use of force or threat of harm against a current or former spouse, cohabitant, dating partner, or parent of your child.

It is important to remember that you can be charged even if there is no visible injury or physical contact. Verbal threats, emotional outbursts, or misunderstandings can be construed as criminal behavior, especially when supported by a misleading or exaggerated report.

This is why it is crucial to examine every aspect of the case closely, particularly when there is no physical evidence of domestic violence.

Defense Strategies for False Accusations

Successfully defending against a false domestic violence accusation requires a detailed investigation, strategic planning, and aggressive legal action. Here are some of the most effective defense strategies:

Inconsistent or Contradictory Witness Statements

Domestic violence cases often rely heavily on witness testimony, especially the statements made by the alleged victim. A skilled defense attorney in San Diego will carefully compare:

• Statements made at the time of the incident
• Police reports
• Written declarations submitted to the court
• Testimony given under oath

Inconsistencies, omissions, or contradictions in these accounts can raise serious doubts about the credibility of the accuser. Cross-examination during a restraining order hearing or criminal trial may expose these discrepancies.

Lack of Corroborating Evidence

In many cases, the only evidence is the accuser’s word. When there is no physical evidence of domestic violence, such as bruises, injuries, damaged property, or medical reports, your attorney can argue that the accusation is unsupported.

Surveillance footage, 911 call recordings, text messages, and social media posts may also be used to contradict the accuser’s version of events or to show that you were not even present at the time of the alleged incident.

Exposing the Accuser’s Motive for Lying

Family court battles, child custody disputes, and divorce proceedings often create incentives for one party to make false claims. If the accuser has a clear motive to lie, your defense attorney can highlight this in court. This may involve examining family law filings, reviewing timelines, or presenting evidence that the accuser has made similar false allegations in the past.

Restraining Order Defense

A restraining order defense is often your first opportunity to contest a false accusation. In California, courts can issue a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) immediately upon request by the alleged victim.

Within weeks of an arrest, a hearing is held to determine whether the order should become permanent. This is a critical moment in your case. With proper legal representation, you can:

• Cross-examine the accuser
• Present witnesses
• Introduce texts, videos, or other evidence
• Argue that the claim is not credible

If your challenge is successful, the court may deny the permanent order, strengthening your position in the criminal case that follows.

Character Witnesses and Background Checks

If you have never had a history of violence, presenting evidence of your clean record and good character can influence both judges and juries. Character witnesses, such as coworkers, neighbors, or mutual friends, can also testify to your demeanor and behavior. This strategy is especially useful when the alleged victim has a known history of manipulative behavior or has made accusations against others.

Can a False Domestic Violence Case Be Dismissed in California?

Yes. A domestic violence case can be dismissed under certain conditions:

• Lack of evidence
• Inconsistencies in the accuser’s story
• Violation of your constitutional rights
• Failure of the accuser to appear in court
• Prosecution chooses not to proceed

In some cases, your lawyer may file a motion to dismiss the charges early in the process. In others, the goal is to prepare a strong trial defense that encourages the District Attorney to drop the charges or offer a favorable resolution.

What to Do If You Are Falsely Accused

If you are facing a false domestic violence accusation in San Diego, it is vital to avoid actions that could be misinterpreted or used against you. Here are steps to protect yourself:

1. Do not contact the accuser even to “clear things up.” Doing so may violate a temporary order and lead to more charges.
2. Comply with all court orders to avoid appearing noncompliant or aggressive.
3. Document everything, including messages, emails, voicemails, and any other communication.
4. Hire a criminal defense lawyer immediately to evaluate your case and guide you through the legal process.

Why Choose jD Law Criminal Defense Attorneys?

At jD Law Criminal Defense Attorneys, we know how devastating a false accusation can be. These cases require more than legal knowledge—they demand investigative skills, attention to detail, and the ability to expose the truth.

Attorney James N. Dicks brings a unique advantage: as a former LAPD investigator, he understands how domestic violence cases are built and how to dismantle them. He is a Certified Criminal Law Specialist, which is a designation held by a small percentage of California attorneys, reflecting his deep experience and successful record in criminal defense.

Whether you are fighting a restraining order, seeking to have a domestic violence case dismissed, or preparing for trial, we will stand by your side with skilled representation at every step.

Speak With Our Experienced Domestic Violence Defense Attorney in San Diego

False allegations do not just threaten your freedom—they threaten your family, your career, and your reputation. If you have been falsely accused, the time to act is now.

Call jD Law Criminal Defense Attorneys today at (760) 630-2000 for a consultation. Our San Diego domestic violence defense lawyer will review the facts, build a powerful defense, and help you take the first step toward clearing your name.